Historical Reality: Infanticide vs Abortion

From the recent interview with Napoleon Chagnon (which we discuss in post “Outstanding Edge interview with Napoleon Chagnon“):

DENNETT: Would you imagine discovering a behavior, a practice, a policy in a tribe that was so repugnant to Western sensibilities that you would decide not to write about that?

CHAGNON: Well, the Yanomamö practice infanticide occasionally, and it’s for a variety of reasons. One of them being if they suspect that the newborn infant is deformed, and it can be traced right back to parental investment. Why invest in a losing prospect? Let’s terminate the infant now and start anew. Another example of infanticide is, this is even rarer, that some guy was cuckolded by, or suspected he was cuckolded by some other guy, and he puts pressure on his wife to kill the new infant. That’s not very common, but I’ve heard of it. And I began reporting, as soon as I learned this, that the Yanomamö practice infanticide, and I didn’t make a big case out of it. When I learned that a deputado in the Venezuelan government—which is basically like a representative or a senator—had learned that there were people in her country that were killing their own children, she wanted to go in and arrest these people and put them in jail. So I stopped reporting any information I acquired about Yanomamö infanticide, not because it was disgusting to Westerners, because I’ll bet if you looked at the abortion rate in Venezuela in middle class women, their rate of abortion would be much, much higher than the Yanomamö infanticide.

PINKER: Well, in fact, historically, I’ve seen an estimate—it averages over many peoples, and there’s a lot of variation underneath it—that the traditional infanticide rate was about 15 percent of live births, which is pretty close to the …

CHAGNON: In Western culture?

PINKER: No No, in non-Western cultures. Which is pretty close to the abortion rate in the West, until recently.

CHAGNON: Oh, really?

PINKER: The abortion rate has since then come down. But there is something to the idea that abortion in the West serves a similar purpose to infanticide in traditional cultures.

CHAGNON: That’s right. It’s a definitional matter, so don’t get uptight about Yanomamö practicing infanticide when your sister or your wife has had an abortion. I mean if you want to make a moral issue out of it, let’s include everybody.

It’s this sort of frank discussion that you see missing from both liberal and conservative pundits today.

A few thoughts:

– In hunter gather societies, it seems that infanticide was widespread.  This practice continues into ancient agricultural societies.  For instance, in Ancient Greece, Ancient Rome and Medieval Europe, infanticide was still quite common.  This would involve disposing of the infant, infant exposure, strangulation,  or more dramatic events like Spartans throwing “defective babies” from cliffs.

– Contrary to the impression given by many pro-life advocates, the infanticide rate throughout almost all of human history was just as high as, if not higher than, modern abortion rates.

– The decline of infanticide in Europe in the 18th and 19th centuries probably had more to do with industrialization releasing Europeans from the constraints of a Malthusian existence than with any change in morality.

Related:

Outstanding Edge interview with Napoleon Chagnon

Cultural Anthropologists: Small-Minded Guardians of Political Correctness

Is ‘Natural Law’ Anti-Nature?”

Updates:

Langer on infanticide: During the Middle Ages, exposure was a prevalent practice due to overpopulation and the large numbers of illegitimate births. During the Renaissance in Italy, the abandonment rate was in excess of 50 percent of all babies. In seventeenth-century China, Jesuit missionaries reported that thousands of infants, mostly female, were deposited in the streets. In 1741 Thomas Coram, a retired sea captain, was so disturbed by the sight of infant corpses lying in the gutters and rotting on dung heaps that he opened Foundling Hospital in England to ‘suppress the inhuman custom of exposing new-born infants to perish in the streets’.

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Historical Reality: Infanticide vs Abortion

  1. Pingback: Outstanding Edge interview with Napoleon Chagnon | Occam's Razor

  2. Pingback: Cultural Anthropologists: Small-Minded Guardians of Political Correctness | Occam's Razor

    • Infanticide seems to be largely driven by the mother finding the baby genetically subpar. Abortion is probably more driven by the mother finding the father genetically subpar.

  3. “practice infanticide occasionally, and it’s for a variety of reasons. One of them being if they suspect that the newborn infant is deformed, and it can be traced right back to parental investment. Why invest in a losing prospect? Let’s terminate the infant now and start anew. ”

    My parents told me that this action happened quite often in Britain before it became the custom to give birth in hospitals. Suppose some not very prosperous family already has four children to raise: a fifth who happens to be healthy might be coped with, but a fifth who’s going to be a great burden would be too much.

  4. What I find interesting here is that the reason infanticide wouldn’t be discussed so openly (in mainstream discourse) is that by doing so, it shows exactly what abortion really is – the killing of one’s offspring.

    In any sane world, if western sensibilities were so offended by infanticide, the same logic would refute any moral foundation for abortion. Instead, we pretend that its not really a baby until some magical point has passed (24-28 weeks), and so abortion is the same as blowing your nose, its simply a case of getting rid of some gunk thats managed to accumulate in your system.

  5. Pingback: Is “Natural Law” Anti-Nature? | Occam's Razor

  6. Pingback: linkfest – 06/10/13 | hbd* chick

  7. The problem of infanticide in East Timor is increasing with several cases being reported recently. These cases have been compiled and reported on the East Timor Law and Justice Bulletin. Accoring to the State Secretary for Equality Promotion, the throwing away of babies in East Timor happens in every village and is mostly committed by young girls who are still at school who have fallen pregnant with an unwanted child.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s